Image may be NSFW.
Clik here to view.
If you're the sort of fantasy owner who uses velocity as a key indicator of a pitcher's potential, then there's a decent chance you've been dealing with a Max Scherzer problem this season.
Scherzer has never thrown harder at any point in his career as a starter (93.9 mph average fastball), and he's never struck out batters at a greater rate (11.2 K/9). And still, he's been absolute torture for fantasy owners. He's failed to complete five innings in four of 12 starts, his ERA is 5.88 and his WHIP is an obscene 1.59. The BABIP seems unreasonably high (.378), sure, but Scherzer has also given up plenty of hard contact (13 homers allowed, 22.7 line-drive rate).
Max has a friendly two-start week on deck — at Wrigley against the wretched Cubs, at home against the (possibly) Tulo-less Rockies — but it's a guessing game with this guy, every time he takes the hill. Scott just went over the grotty details on Thursday, and I can only echo his bottom line: "Stop the ride, I'd like to get off."
I've got no Scherzer shares this week, because...well, because I'm a coward. I accept the possibility that he may very well strike out 30 hitters over 14.0 innings in his next two starts, winning twice. But it's the flip side that gets me, his potential to allow 14 runs over four innings. For now (and maybe for good), I'm out. If you're still rolling with the heterochromatic hurler, let's hear about it in comments.
AMERICAN LEAGUE
Hell yeah
Brandon Morrow — WAS (Jackson), PHI (Kendrick)
Colby Lewis — ARI (Kennedy), HOU (Norris)
Felix Hernandez — SD (Richard), SF (Bumgarner)
Sure, OK. I can see it
Josh Beckett — at MIA (Johnson), at CHC (Maholm)
Ivan Nova — at ATL (Delgado), at WAS (Jackson)
Wei-Yin Chen — PIT (Lincoln), at ATL (Delgado)
Smart move for you — I'm not doin' it, but I like this move for other people's rosters
Max Scherzer — at CHC (Maholm), COL (Guthrie)
Not officially endorsed. But hey, it's your team
Bartolo Colon — at COL (Guthrie), SD (Richard)
Garrett Richards — at LAD (Capuano), ARI (Kennedy)
Alex Cobb — NYM (Young), MIA (Johnson)
Eep
Jose Quintana — at STL (Wainwright), at LAD (Capuano)
Jeanmar Gomez — at CIN (Cueto), PIT (Lincoln)
Luis Mendoza — MIL (Greinke), at STL (Wainwright)
Nick Blackburn — PHI (Kendrick), MIL (Greinke)
Image may be NSFW.
Clik here to view.
NATIONAL LEAGUE
If you can't win the pitching categories this week, the blame won't fall on these guys...
Zack Greinke — at KC (Mendoza), at MIN (Blackburn)
Madison Bumgarner — HOU (Norris), at SEA (Hernandez)
Full approval, all leagues
Ian Kennedy — at TEX (Lewis), at LAA (Richards)
Josh Johnson — BOS (Beckett), at TB (Cobb)
Adam Wainwright — CWS (Quintana), KC (Mendoza)
Chris Capuano — LAA (Richards), CWS (Quintana)
Johnny Cueto — CLE (Gomez), at NYM (Young)
I'm not doing it, because I carry grudges against these two. But they're better than the next batch
Bud Norris — at SF (Bumgarner), at TEX (Lewis)
Edwin Jackson — at TOR (Morrow), NYY (Nova)
Don't think I'd do this intentionally, except in a deep league
Kyle Kendrick — at MIN (Blackburn), at TOR (Morrow)
Clayton Richard — at SEA (Hernandez), at OAK (Colon)
Randall Delgado — NYY (Nova), BAL (Chen)
Chris Young — at TB (Cobb), CIN (Cueto)
Brad Lincoln — at BAL (Chen), at CLE (Gomez)
Just...bad. No
Paul Maholm — DET (Scherzer), BOS (Beckett)
Jeremy Guthrie — OAK (Colon), at DET (Scherzer)